Do we need more posts about the Big SEO tools or should we block them?

[blazonstudio]

Personally my favorite posts on this subreddit are updates, like big updates in the SEO space, whether that’s a core update or something like when Adobe was acquiring SEMrush. That stuff definitely interests me.

I would also say I love when people ask real questions and not just leading questions to get them to be able to spam the comments with a tool they’re trying to sell. When someone actually has an issue or needs clarification on something, I know that tends to be more beginner focused but I do enjoy helping folks on those posts and just hearing what other people are dealing with.

At this point I’m kind of jaded to even take a post seriously that talks about results they’ve gotten, in particular if it’s good. If someone’s having really bad results for something honestly, that’s more approachable and I’m more likely to engage but it just seems like phishing at this point when someone posts about a new tool that they’re making or some amazing result that they got.

[Legitimate-Salary108]

If the post is about using the tools in some new ways to get certain results, I’m usually interested. But at this point most ‘new’ tricks/tactics aren’t so new to me anymore. So I dunno. 😐

[Nyodrax]

I don’t feel like the tool posts have been crazy in volume; but I do remember commenting on one recently.

I have quite a few thoughts on SEO tooling, but my eyes glaze over when the convo turns to like peec vs otterly lmao

I just do no care about prompt tracking

[jachcemmatnickspace]

For me it’s more about the general post quality.

Good post where somebody nicely describes their problem etc. and isn’t that obvious to everybody = Ok

Post like every other, either really beginner posts or something 1000 times talked about in this sub (why is my page not ranking) I find boring and annoying = No Value for me.

To me it doesnt really matter if they talk about Ahrefs v Semrush or how to index or “why this message in GSC” – things that are really simple, already many times answered etc., are in my opinion just low quality posts.

If I had an issue where I want serious answer, I would spent 20 mins on that post and ideally provide screenshots (i know, not allowed) and as much in-depth info as possible to maximize chances somebody will give me good advice.

The posts Im talking about are just copy-paste 30 seconds posts. Where you usually link one of your guides anyway bcs it has already been answered many times

[SEOPub]

I think tools conversations are okay. There are always new people entering the field. Yes, they can search for old threads, but Reddit’s search function sucks and I don’t think you can rely on Google to surface the best results from here either.

Specifically for Semrush vs Ahrefs, since that comes up a lot, a sticky thread might not be a bad idea.