-
Social SEO killed my agency’s Google strategy and honestly, I’m not even mad about it
Posted by on February 15, 2026 at 3:59 pmThree months ago, I ran an experiment that made me question everything I thought I knew about content distribution.
We manage social for 11 local businesses – restaurants, gyms, a few retail stores. Standard stuff. I'd been pushing them hard on the classic playbook: blog posts optimized for Google, backlinks, the whole SEO song and dance. Solid ROI, nothing crazy.
Then one of our restaurant clients got impatient. "Nobody's finding us on Google," they said. "But everyone's on TikTok looking for places to eat."
I was skeptical. But we ran a test. Took the same budget we'd been spending on blog content and Google Ads, redirected it entirely into TikTok and Instagram Reels. No website changes. No SEO. Just pure social content optimized for in-app search – proper captions, spoken keywords, trending sounds with our own spin.
Within six weeks, their weekend reservations were up 40%. Not from Google. From people searching "best pasta near me" directly in TikTok.
Here's what bothers me: I spent years learning traditional SEO. My whole value prop was built around Google rankings. And now I'm watching 24-year-olds who've never heard of meta descriptions crush it by understanding how TikTok's algorithm surfaces content in search results.
The uncomfortable truth? For local businesses targeting under-35s, traditional SEO might be a waste of money in 2026. These people aren't typing into Google anymore. They're asking TikTok, Instagram, even YouTube before they ever hit a browser.
Now I'm rebuilding everything I know. Learning caption optimization like it's 2015 keyword research all over again. Figuring out which hashtags actually get indexed vs. which ones are just engagement theater. Testing whether voiceovers with specific phrases impact discoverability more than on-screen text.
It's humbling. And honestly, a little exciting. But also terrifying, because if I'm wrong about this pivot, I just killed a revenue stream that was working fine.
Anyone else seeing this shift? Or am I overreacting to one lucky case study?
-
1 Reply
-
This is happening in music marketing too. It’s a real shift, but it’s happening at exactly the same time as users are deleting TikTok. Social is and always will be a moving target.
-
This is 100% the new local playbook, people are basically using social as their primary search engine now. We’ve been leaning into this for our clients too and use Gemin-Eye to find all those ‘where can I find X’ questions across Reddit and local FB groups. It’s way more effective than waiting for them to find a random blog post.
-
Absolutely seeing the same shift with our local clients. Social search is pulling a lot more weight, especially among younger crowds. If you want to track these trends in real time and spot where people are talking about your clients, ParseStream can help by notifying you about relevant conversations across different platforms so you are not missing those new channels.
-
You’re not overreacting. Local SEO is still useful but for under-35s, social platforms are becoming the main search tool.
-
The interesting part is you said “incremental reservations.” That’s the whole thing.
Doesn’t sound like SEO died. Sounds like some under-35 traffic just stopped using Google for discovery and never showed up there in the first place.
If those bookings came from people who weren’t going to search “best restaurant near me” anyway, that’s not collapse. That’s behavior shift. Are you seeing this outside restaurants or is it mostly that vertical?
-
Totally agree for younger audiences, social discovery is becoming more powerful than traditional SEO. I’ve seen similar trends where TikTok and Reels drive actual conversions for local businesses way faster than Google ever did. Optimizing for in app search and trends seems like the future, especially for under 35 audiences
Log in to reply.